Does having open credit cards hurt credit score

What is New Credit?

New credit makes up 10% of a FICO® Score. When you apply for new credit, inquiries remain on your credit report for two years. FICO Scores only consider inquiries from the last 12 months.

People tend to have more credit today and shop for new credit more frequently than ever. FICO Scores reflect this reality. However, research shows that opening several new credit accounts in a short period of time represents greater risk - especially for people who don't have a long credit history. Your FICO Scores take into account several factors when looking at new credit.

Here are the 3 things to look at for the new credit factor:

How many new accounts you have

Your FICO Scores look at how many new accounts you have by type of account. They may also look at how many of your accounts are new accounts.

Don't open new accounts too rapidly.

If you've been managing credit for a short time, don't open a lot of new accounts too rapidly. New accounts will lower your average account age, which will have a larger effect on your FICO Scores if you don't have a lot of other credit information. Even if you have used credit for a long time, opening a new account can still lower your FICO Scores.

How many recent inquiries you have

An inquiry is when a lender makes a request for your credit report or score. Although FICO Scores only consider inquiries from the last 12 months, inquiries remain on your credit report for two years. FICO Scores have been carefully designed to count only those inquiries that truly impact credit risk, as not all inquiries are related to credit risk.

There are 3 important facts about inquiries to note:

  • Inquiries usually have a small impact
  • Many types of inquiries are ignored completely
  • The score allows for "rate shopping"

Remember: It's OK to request and check your own credit report.

Checking your credit report won't affect your FICO Scores, as long as you order your credit report directly from the credit reporting agency or through an organization authorized to provide credit reports to consumers, such as myFICO.

How long it's been since you opened a new account.

This is the age of your most recently opened account. Your FICO Scores may consider the time that has passed since you opened a new credit account, for specific types of accounts.

How new credit can lower FICO Scores

When applying for new credit, an inquiry is placed on your credit report. That means, for instance, if you're trying to get a new credit card, the lender will "inquire" into your credit report from one of the three major credit agencies. Depending on the other factors in your report, this inquiry can lower your score by a few points.

A new credit card or line of credit will also affect your length of credit history. This part of your score is made up of your "oldest" account and the average of all your accounts. Opening new credit lowers the average age of your total accounts. This, in effect, lowers your length of credit history and subsequently, your credit score.

New credit, once used, will increase the "amounts owed" factor of your credit score. Amounts owed is composed of credit utilization — the ratio of your credit balances to your credit limits. Very often, the lower your credit utilization (how much credit you're using compared to your total credit limit), the higher your credit score. When you open and use a new credit card or line of credit, you're getting closer to your credit limit, which could mean a lower score.

How new credit can increase FICO Scores

If the new line of credit helps diversify the types of accounts you currently have, this can increase the "credit mix" factor of your credit score. It shows lenders you can obtain and manage different kinds of credit, which can lower their risk of lending you money.

Let's say you open a new credit card account (which could initially lower your score) and then don't use that card for any new purchases. Over time, this can lower your credit utilization which could mean an increase in your credit score.

If you have a bad "payment history" and are starting from scratch to create a positive one, then opening new credit can help with that. If you can prove to lenders that you can pay your bills on time, this will help increase your score in the long run.

You should carefully consider if you need a new credit account. In the next section, you can learn about how to improve your FICO Score.

Key Points About: How Opening a Credit Card Affects Your Credit Score

  1. Length of credit history and credit utilization ratio are determining factors in a person’s credit score.

  2. Creditors will do a hard inquiry on each new credit line applied for, potentially negatively impacting credit scores.

  3. Impacts to your credit score from opening a new card are less severe than missing payments or closing a longstanding credit card account.

Per FICO, opening a new credit card account can impact your credit score in two primary ways. First, the card issuer will likely pull your credit report as part of their review process. That inquiry on your credit report can lower your score – but generally has a small impact on your FICO® Scores1 (for most people, this means less than five points off their FICO® Score). In addition, the issuer will report the newly opened account to the credit bureaus, which impacts length of credit history characteristics. The exact impact depends on the applicant’s unique credit history. Over time, though, getting a credit card can help build a better credit history if you pay it on time and carry minimal debt (basically using all your credit accounts responsibly). As you build up a history of responsible behavior, and it’s reported to the major credit bureaus, you can be on your way to a better financial future.

Those are far from the only ways that opening a credit card can potentially impact your credit score – see below for more details.

How opening a credit card can help your credit score

Responsible handling of your finances, potentially with the opening and use of a credit card, can help build a good credit history over time. For example, while FICO® Scores are made up of several components, one important category is amounts owed, which typically makes up 30 percent of your overall score. This component addresses your debt-to-credit ratio, or credit utilization rate. Essentially, it measures how much of the credit extended to you, also known as your credit limit, is being used and paid off. Per FICO, a low credit utilization rate will more positively affect your FICO® Scores than not using your available credit at all because it shows that you are capable of handling credit responsibly.

How many credit cards do you need to build credit? The answer depends on your credit utilization and how much credit you need, so consider the ratio of how much you spend compared to how much credit is available to you on your card, or cards. For example, opening a credit card may lower your debt-to-credit ratio. Say that you double your total credit lines available from $5,000 to $10,000 by opening a second card, but you simply spread out your current spending of about $1,000 per month across those two credit cards. This would improve your utilization ratio, meaning that you’re spending $1,000 out of $10,000 available to you, for a utilization of 10 percent instead of 20 percent when you had $5,000 available.

But remember, using more credit could make you less likely to pay back what you’ve borrowed. A high utilization ratio fits the profile of someone who might be “living on credit.” That’s a fiscally dangerous way to live, and a higher risk for potential lenders. Whenever possible, you should try not to use all your available credit.

Could getting a new credit card hurt your credit score?

Despite all of the ways that a new credit card can help your credit score, there’s always the potential for it to hurt your score under certain circumstances.

For example, if you were to open up several new lines of credit in a short period of time, you may see a drop in your FICO® Scores. Applying for several new credit cards could be seen as a sign of riskier spending, and the credit scoring formulas could penalize consumers for opening multiple accounts within a few months’ time.

Also, if having a new credit card account leads to incurring more debt and the potential to exceed your credit limit, then your credit score also can suffer. And if having too many accounts causes you to make late payments, then that could hurt your credit score.

Another way that getting a new credit card can hurt your credit is if you use a balance transfer offer to transfer the balance of a loan to your new credit card, which can increase your debt-to-credit ratio and reduce your mix of credit.

Finally, opening a new credit card will reduce the average age of your accounts, especially if you have few credit cards and they have all been open for a long time. Having a low average age of accounts is a factor in having a low credit sore. About 15% of your FICO® Score is determined by the length of your credit history.

Does pre-approval for a credit card lower your credit score?

Whether you get a pre-approval offer or fill out a form for pre-approval, your credit score is usually not affected. This is because pre-approval uses what’s known as a soft inquiry on your credit report, meaning the credit card issuer is checking your credit history, but will not complete a hard inquiry until you formally apply for credit. Soft inquiries don’t affect your credit score.

When you build a good credit history by using your credit card responsibly, it could open up an opportunity to get a credit card that provides a cashback rewards program. For example, some cards offer cash bonuses, while others offer cash back rewards or miles, and many of these cards are available with no annual fee.

If you’ve got an excellent credit score, you may score a lower interest rate on your card, or have more reward options as issuers compete for your business. In short, having excellent credit gives you more choices. As you research credit cards, remember that the best cards tend to offer the best overall benefits that are most valuable to you, relative to the cost.

Reasons to avoid a low credit score

By contrast, having a low credit score can make life more difficult when it comes to applying for a personal loan, renting an apartment, or getting a mortgage, for example. It may also cost you more money in the long run, as you may have to pay higher interest rates on the loans you are able to get. Larger, more reputable lenders may be reluctant to loan you money if you have a lower credit score, so you may be forced to borrow from less-than-reputable sources, such as payday lenders or title loan companies. These types of lenders often charge extremely high interest rates. In addition, your credit data may impact your insurance premiums, your career prospects, even your ability to access utilities, such as electricity, water and the internet. Individuals with a poor credit history often pay higher fees for auto and homeowners policies, and employers may be hesitant to hire you if they pull your credit report and don’t like what they see. Many utility providers require customers with bad credit to pay a security deposit upfront or submit a letter of guarantee, which acts like a co-signer or guarantor if you fall behind on your payments. Finally, you may miss out on the best rewards credit cards. Access to these cards typically requires you to have a high credit score to get the best introductory and balance transfer offers and cash back incentives. Discover offers multiple rewards credit cards for students and those new to credit. You can check to see if you qualify for pre-approval for a new credit card with Discover without hurting your credit score.

Factors that can lower your credit score besides applying for a credit card

Although opening a credit card may cause your credit score to be lower temporarily, other factors can also contribute to a low credit score.

High credit card balances

If you have recently made some large purchases and only paid the minimum due on your credit card, this can hurt your debt-to-credit ratio, and may be responsible for your credit score being lower than it was.

Missed payments

If you missed a payment on one of your cards last month, or if you paid your mortgage late, you could see a significant drop in your credit score. Late payments have a big impact on your credit score..

Recently closed accounts

Just as opening a new credit card decreases the average age of your accounts, closing an older account will decrease the average age of those that remain. If a card you don’t use has no annual fee, it may be more helpful to keep the account open and just use the card often enough so that the issuer doesn’t close it for lack of use.

The bottom line

One of the keys to having an excellent credit score is to establish a history of paying your bills on time, and carrying very little debt. The next time you see a competitive offer for a credit card, you can consider how the application may impact your credit score when deciding whether to apply. And as you build excellent credit, you can start to reap the benefits in terms of more flexible personal financial tools. 

Does your credit score go down when you open credit cards?

Applying for a new credit card can trigger a hard inquiry, which involves a lender looking at your credit reports. According to credit-scoring company FICO®, hard inquiries can cause a slight drop in your credit scores. Keep in mind: Hard inquiries usually stay on your credit reports for two years.

Is it better to cancel unused credit cards or keep them?

In general, it's best to keep unused credit cards open so that you benefit from a longer average credit history and a larger amount of available credit. Credit scoring models reward you for having long-standing credit accounts, and for using only a small portion of your credit limit.